A few years ago, I posted a question on my Instagram story asking people whether they felt more connected to their city, state, region of the country, or the nation as a whole. Most people answered their state.
I’ve always thought Alabama had a particularly distinct sense of state pride. Maybe it’s because there isn’t necessarily anything especially impressive about the place besides the people who live there. We love our culture. We like feeding family and friends, making people smile, and asking thoughtful questions. We take pride in being simple, kind, and crafty. Most women I know learned how to sew at some point, and plenty still enjoy going to church with their grandma every once in a while.
We need community. It’s the pillar of our whole existence.
Talking nonstop about our not-so-good college football teams and the wonders of Alabama white sauce never gets old because those things are part of our roots. There’s something comforting about sharing so many seemingly insignificant things with the people around you. For all our differences, there’s a familiarity that makes strangers feel like people you’ve known forever. Of course, Alabama has its divisions and contradictions, and Southern hospitality has never been extended equally to everyone. But there’s something special about growing up somewhere that makes you feel so connected to the people around you.
Alabama shapes you.
I could just feel this way because I’m nostalgic and destined to be homesick until I die. Even though I’ve accepted that I may never move back home, I love where I’m from. I couldn’t imagine being me if I had grown up anywhere else. Being from the South is actually one of my favorite things about myself.
But sometimes I wonder if I’ll always be Southern.
And what about my kids? Is that something I can pass down? Can they be half Southern and half West Coast if I just say “y’all” a lot and cram a bunch of traditions down their throats during the holidays? Will they feel any particular connection to a place they’ve never lived, or will Alabama just be somewhere they visit to see relatives?
I guess these aren’t things I need to be worrying about right now. Still, throughout this long journey of self-discovery, the question has been floating around in the back of my mind.
What made me realize just how paranoid I was about giving up my Southern roots was an interaction I had last summer.
I was hanging out with a guy I knew from high school who now lives near me. He mentioned wanting to move to my dream city in a few years, although only temporarily, and that he could really see himself settling down in Southern California.
Naturally, I took the fact that we wanted to live in the same city around the same time, and that our parents would be relatively close to one another, as a sign that perhaps I was going to marry this man.
A man I had never even kissed, despite knowing him for almost a decade.
Pure delusion.
The fact that convenience alone was enough to make me start hypothesizing about our future together was crazy. But for about 45 minutes, it felt like the only scenario that could ever make sense because it was the only one where I didn’t see myself having to make some enormous sacrifice. I could build the life I wanted in California with someone who already understood the place I came from. Our hypothetical children could have both.
Not that we had ever discussed children. Or marriage. Or even going on a date.
It’s interesting that I frame the possibility of losing my Southern identity in such a catastrophic way because there’s no real reason for me to be grieving this fantasy of Southern manners and familiarity. I haven’t stopped being Southern just because I moved to California. I can still call people “ma’am,” ask strangers about their families, and spend entirely too much time talking to someone I only intended to greet.
Still, it’s hard sometimes to imagine a world that feels smaller than the one I’ve always known.
Which is strange, considering how much bigger my world has gotten since leaving Alabama. I’ve traveled, moved across the country, and met people whose experiences are completely different from mine. There’s so much I love about that. I wouldn’t trade the opportunity to experience different ways of living just to remain somewhere familiar.
But I grew up in a place where everybody felt like a distant cousin and I generally assumed the best of everyone. I wouldn’t always remember to lock my door. I could sleep at some friend of a friend’s house for no particular reason. People love to talk even more than me (hard to believe, I’m sure).
I know some of this is nostalgia. Not everybody in Alabama is welcoming, and plenty of people in California are. I also recognize that the version of home I remember is shaped by the freedom and simplicity of being a child. Maybe what I miss isn’t entirely about geography.
It’s possible that I’ve been attributing parts of my personality to the South that I would have developed regardless of where I grew up. Would I still be the person who loves hosting, talking to strangers, and making friends everywhere I go if I’d been raised somewhere else? Or did living in Alabama teach me to see those things as essential parts of life?
I don’t know.
I do know that I want my future children to understand where I came from. I want them to know the people, hear the stories, and appreciate the traditions that meant so much to me. But I also wonder how much of culture can actually be taught. There are things you learn through experience that are difficult to explain to someone who wasn’t there.
And maybe they’ll grow up loving California the way I love Alabama. Maybe they’ll have their own collection of seemingly insignificant things that make them feel connected to home. Maybe they’ll think I’m ridiculous for being so attached to a place I haven’t lived in for decades.
I hope they do develop that kind of attachment to somewhere, even if it isn’t the same place as mine.
I suppose there’s also the possibility that I’ll change more than I expect. That the longer I live somewhere else, the more my habits, expectations, and understanding of people will change with me. After all, isn’t that part of the reason we leave home in the first place? To discover things about ourselves that we couldn’t have learned by staying?
I don’t want to spend my life trying to preserve a version of myself that only existed because of where I happened to grow up. But I don’t want to lose sight of her, either.
Maybe I’ll always be nostalgic and homesick. Maybe I’ll never stop talking about Alabama, and maybe I’ll spend the rest of my life finding little pieces of it in people and places that are nothing like home.
I wonder whether my attachment to the South comes from the way I was taught to love people, or whether my love for people is what made the South feel so special to me in the first place.
And if I can no longer tell the difference, does it really matter?
Leave a Reply